Value of CoP: Blue collection / Garfield signed Phelddagrif

[Desert_Bus]

I have no idea what this collection is worth so here's a list. Please help me appraise it.

Circle of Protection: Blue:
11 Alpha
1 Alpha signed - Willich
17 Beta
17 Unlimited
3 Collectors Edition
1 International Collectors Edition
104 Revised
1 Revised signed - Willich
1 Summer Edition
121 4th Edition (may include alpha cut 4th Edition, I dunno)
6 Alternate 4th Edition
1 4th Edition artist proof signed - Willich
1 1994 Italian black border
8 1994 German black border
1 1995 German
1 1995 French black border
1 1995 French
150 Ice Age
1 Ice Age artist proof signed - Venters
1 Ice Age German signed - Venters
1 1996 Japanese black border artist proof signed - Willich
3 1996 Korean black border
5 1996 Chinese black border
26 5th Edition
105 Tempest
1 Tempest Japanese (supposedly a misprint, but I can't read Japanese)
18 6th edition
16 7th Edition
3 7th Edition foil
10 8th Edition
8 8th Edition Foil
10 Rune of Protection: Blue (all mutilated)

1 Phelddagrif signed and customized - Richard Garfield (since it rearranges to Garfield Phd., he drew a little graduation cap on it.)

95% of these are NM, and all the rarer ones like the signed ones, the artist proofs, the Summer Magic, etc. are NM. I think the only missing rarity is Alpha cut 4th, and like I said, there may be some in the 121 cards in the 4th Edition section. I think it comes out to 655 COP: Blue, 10 ROP: Blue, and the Phelddagrif.

[dragsamou]

I have no idea what this collection is worth so here's a list. Please help me appraise it.

Hi and welcome

Is it a Collection, you want to buy or sell ?
Japanese Tempest COP Blue Misprint, not aware of a Misprint version.

[Desert_Bus]

I'm planning on selling it and the Garfield signed Phelddagrif.

I know I heard somewhere ages ago that the Japanese Tempest read "black" instead of "blue" or something, but I never really looked into it. Owning it was the important part. I really should look more into it.

And should I specify if the card was signed with ballpoint or marker?

[effai]

for the COP, I would say the price pretty much runs around the value of the summer + alphas, since the global set isn't complete at all, but maybe you can find someone who's interested in accumulation of the same card

[mmgun]

I know I heard somewhere ages ago that the Japanese Tempest read "black" instead of "blue" or something, but I never really looked into it. Owning it was the important part. I really should look more into it.

About the Cop Issue:

All Korean 5th Edition Cops ( Blue,Green,White,Red) have the text of Cop: Black. That is for sure.
Maybe you mixed that info up with your japanese tempest one ?

But a readable picture of your Cop should solve the issue, please post.

[mmgun]

maybe someone can read it ? The first letter in the cardname specifies the color.

Black:


Blue

[dragsamou]

maybe someone can read it ? The first letter in the cardname specifies the color.

Black:


Blue

According to MTG Wiki Japanese:
http://goo.gl/pGj392

COP Blue 青の防御円
(１)：このターン、あなたが選んだ青の発生源１つが次にあなたに与えるすべてのダメージを軽減する。

青 = Blue

COP Black 黒の防御円
(１)：このターン、あなたが選んだ黒の発生源１つが次にあなたに与えるすべてのダメージを軽減する。

黒= Black

[Desert_Bus]

Ok, if I slim down the list to this:

11 Alpha
1 Alpha signed - Willich
17 Beta
3 Collectors Edition
1 International Collectors Edition
1 Revised signed - Willich
1 Summer Edition
6 Alternate 4th Edition
1 4th Edition artist proof signed - Willich
1 Ice Age artist proof signed - Venters
1 Ice Age German signed - Venters
1 1996 Japanese black border artist proof signed - Willich
3 7th Edition foil
8 8th Edition Foil

Is it easier to give a rough value?

And that Phelddagrif? I know nothing about Garfield signed cards, less about Garfield related Garfield signed cards, and even less about Garfield related Garfield signed cards with Garfield artwork, and way less about Garfield related Garfield signed cards with Garfield artwork appropriate to the symbolism of the name of the card.